Jane Street TDO Earlier US Finals: 19 Experiences (Part 7 of 10)
- Company
- Jane Street
- Level
- Unknown
- Stages
- OA → Phone screen → Onsite
Jane Street TDO finals in the US, reports from 2016 to early 2023: an Excel test, a maths call and VBA came before process and coding rounds.
At a glance
- Process (these earlier reports): Excel take-home → phone maths or brainteaser call → VBA take-home → a New York final or superday. Seven reports give this order (H03, H04, H09, H11, H12, H13, H18).
- Asked: the weekday years later (H03–H05), coin odds (H03, H04) and haircut sheets (H03, H07, H10, H13). Finals: process talk (H01, H13, H16, H18), coding (H01, H10, H16, H17).
- Difficulty: phone maths felt not hard (H04) or elementary (H12); VBA was somewhat challenging (H12) or took time to learn (H04); H11's onsite felt hard and unfamiliar.
- Practise first: Day of the Week Years Later (H03–H05), Heads in Fair Coin Flips (H03, H04), Post-Trade Settlement Pipeline (H16; closest practice for H13, H18).
Coverage: 19 US reports from before Nov 2023, 9 from New York and 10 with no city, titled TDO, Trade Desk Operations or Trading Desk Operation(s). None states a hiring level. May 2016 (report date) to Feb 2023 (report date). All but two took a final, onsite or superday: H07 names it only as a later step, and H15 withdrew before it.
In this series
- Part 1: overview, questions and what to practise, 165 reports
- Part 2: UK final round, 14 reports
- Part 3: UK coding round, 15 reports
- Part 4: UK phone screen, 15 reports
- Part 5: US final round, 11 reports
- Part 6: US phone screen, 20 reports
- Part 7 (current): earlier US finals, 19 reports
- Part 8: Excel and VBA test (earlier), 23 reports
- Part 9: phone math round (earlier), 26 reports
- Part 10: UK and Hong Kong (earlier), 22 reports
What came up
Nearly all of these reached the final, so the whole funnel shows.
| Topic | Reports | Last seen |
|---|---|---|
| Maths, logic or brainteaser questions | 13 of 19 | Jun 2022 |
| Excel take-home or test | 12 of 19 | Jun 2022 |
| VBA task | 10 of 19 | Jun 2022 |
| Process or design talk at the final | 4 of 19 | Feb 2023 (report date) |
| Coding at the final | 4 of 19 | Feb 2023 (report date) |
| Day of the week years later | 3 of 19 | Jun 2022 |
Questions in these earlier reports
Counted only within these 19 reports.
Excel, VBA and data tasks
| Question | Reports | Last seen |
|---|---|---|
| VBA take-home, task not given (not on FastPrep: topic only) | 9 | Jun 2022 |
| Excel take-home, contents not given (not on FastPrep: topic only) | 8 | Apr 2022 (report date) |
| Haircut sheet, rules not given (not on FastPrep: topic only) | 3 | Jun 2022 |
| Order book validation (closest practice) | 1 | Feb 2023 (report date) |
| Currency haircut, total in USD | 1 | Sep 2018 |
Coding
| Question | Reports | Last seen |
|---|---|---|
| Coding or pseudo-code, no prompt given (not on FastPrep: topic only) | 3 | Feb 2023 (report date) |
| Largest single mover, longest rising run | 1 | Oct 2017 |
Maths, probability and brainteasers
| Question | Reports | Last seen |
|---|---|---|
| Brainteasers, logic or critical thinking (not on FastPrep: topic only) | 5 | Oct 2018 (report date) |
| Probability questions, not described (not on FastPrep: topic only) | 4 | Sep 2018 |
| Day of the week N years later | 3 | Jun 2022 |
| Heads in two or three fair coins | 2 | Jun 2022 |
| Date-format question (closest practice) | 1 | Jun 2022 |
| Largest number whose digits multiply to 96 | 1 | Apr 2022 (report date) |
| Count the 2s from 1 to one million | 1 | Mar 2019 (report date) |
| The bus question (not on FastPrep: topic only) | 1 | Mar 2018 |
| Clock-hand angle at several times | 1 | May 2017 (report date) |
| Card problems (not on FastPrep: topic only) | 1 | May 2016 (report date) |
Low-Level Design (LLD)
| Question | Reports | Last seen |
|---|---|---|
| Order messages between a trading firm and an exchange | 1 | Feb 2023 (report date) |
System Design
| Question | Reports | Last seen |
|---|---|---|
| Risks or checks in an explained process (closest practice) | 2 | Mar 2018 |
| Make trades settle and flow smoothly | 1 | Oct 2017 |
Discussion and knowledge rounds
| Question | Reports | Last seen |
|---|---|---|
| Onsite rounds, no task content (not on FastPrep: no task content) | 2 | Sep 2018 |
| Pennies in your city (not on FastPrep: discussion only) | 1 | Nov 2021 |
| A question about ATS (not on FastPrep: discussion only) | 1 | Oct 2018 (report date) |
| Exercise like daily operations work (not on FastPrep: topic only) | 1 | Nov 2017 |
| How the firm is organised (not on FastPrep: discussion only) | 1 | May 2017 (report date) |
| Quantitative case analysis (not on FastPrep: topic only) | 1 | May 2016 (report date) |
Behavioral (BQ)
| Question | Reports | Last seen |
|---|---|---|
| What value would you bring? | 1 | Sep 2018 |
History (before Nov 2023)
H01: Pseudo-code, order book checks and order flow
Report date: Feb 2023 · Location: United States · Result: Not stated
Earlier rounds not described. Three final interviews: pseudo-code (task not given), order book validation (questions not given; Order Book Data Validation is the closest practice) and order flow. An order book is the list of orders waiting to trade. One task: design the messages between a trading firm and an exchange, with how many message types and what each carries. No behavioral questions.
H02: Two take-homes to a superday, process only
Report date: Nov 2022 · Location: United States · Result: Not stated
Two take-homes (types not named), one technical interview, then a three-round superday. The candidate could not recall the questions.
H03: Coins, a date and a future weekday
Interview date: Jun 2022 · Location: United States · Result: Accepted an offer (outcome field)
(1) Excel take-home of haircut problems; a haircut is the cut taken off a position's value to cover its risk. (2) Phone: chance of at least one head with two fair coins (Heads in Fair Coin Flips); a date-format question, not described (Next Date With All Different Digits is the closest practice); the weekday on a future date (Day of the Week Years Later). (3) VBA (Excel's macro language) take-home. (4) A final, not described.
H04: Three phone questions, then VBA
Report date: Apr 2022 · Location: United States · Result: Not stated
Basic Excel take-home with some finance. Phone, three questions the candidate found not hard: the weekday 10 years from now, 2 heads in three coin flips and the largest number whose digits multiply to 96. Then a VBA take-home (VBA takes time to learn) and an onsite, not described.
H05: Friday 8 July 2022, ten years on
Interview date: Feb 2022 · Location: United States · Result: Not stated
About four rounds, heavy on Excel and VBA (tasks not given); the final was with engineers. One question, round not given: if today is Friday 8 July 2022, what weekday is 8 July 2032? (Day of the Week Years Later)
H06: Pennies in the city, then a cold final
Interview date: Nov 2021 · Location: New York · Result: Not stated
Two interviews and an Excel assignment went fine (contents not given). Estimate, round not given: how many pennies are in your city? At the final, the interviewers seemed uninterested from the start.
H07: Haircut take-home via a staffing firm
Report date: Oct 2019 · Location: United States · Result: Not stated
Excel take-home: the haircut on a given portfolio. Basic Excel, no VBA, tedious instructions. Told a phone call, another assessment and a superday would follow.
H08: Three phone interviews and a count of 2s
Report date: Mar 2019 · Location: United States · Result: Accepted an offer (outcome field)
A take-home test, three phone interviews of about 40 to 60 minutes, then an in-person interview. One question, round not given: writing every number from 1 to one million, how many 2s do you write? (Count the 2s From 1 to n)
H09: An onsite that weighed every word
Report date: Oct 2018 · Location: New York · Result: Not stated
Excel test, critical-thinking phone call, VBA test, onsite. The interviewers were kind but weighed the exact words of each answer and assumed nothing. One question was about ATS (not spelled out).
H10: USD haircut total, then coding and fit
Interview date: Sep 2018 · Location: New York · Result: Declined an offer
Excel sheet of simple problems, among them the total USD haircut on the given positions (Currency Haircut with FX Forwards; rules not described). Critical-thinking phone call. In person: coding (not described) and what value would you bring?
H11: Hard onsite, with hints
Interview date: Sep 2018 · Location: New York · Result: No offer
Excel test of three questions; phone on probability and brainteasers; a VBA coding task; a New York onsite of hard, unfamiliar questions; interviewers nudged toward answers. No questions given.
H12: Two-hour Excel test, then an offer
Interview date: May 2018 · Location: New York · Result: Declined an offer
About two hours of Excel, not difficult; phone with brainteasers and elementary probability; a somewhat challenging VBA task; an onsite that was mostly brainstorming. No questions given.
H13: Risks in an explained trading system
Interview date: Mar 2018 · Location: New York · Result: Not stated
Excel haircuts; phone with basic probability and simple calculations; a VBA script; a New York onsite, travel paid, where the interviewers explained a trading system and asked about its risks (Post-Trade Settlement Pipeline is the closest practice).
H14: The bus question after a role switch
Interview date: Mar 2018 · Location: New York · Result: Not stated
Applied through school for another role; the recruiter suggested TDO. Three rounds before a New York onsite, with a bus question and a probability question (none described).
H15: On-campus HR chat, then VBA
Interview date: Nov 2017 · Location: New York · Result: No offer (withdrew before the final)
On-campus one-to-one with HR: a few brainteasers and an exercise like daily operations work. VBA take-home, passed. Invited to the New York final; declined.
H16: Superday on settlement, trade flow and price moves
Interview date: Oct 2017 · Location: New York · Result: Not stated
Campus posting. First round not described, then a VBA assignment: the largest single mover in a stock's prices (Biggest Daily Move and Longest Rising Streak). Superday, three groups (two morning, one afternoon). Two on process: how to make sure trades settle, and how to design a smooth trade flow (Post-Trade Settlement Pipeline). One coding: again the largest mover, or the longest run of up days.
H17: Five interviewers and the firm's structure
Report date: May 2017 · Location: United States · Result: Declined an offer
On-campus interview (no detail), then in person with a recruiter, a trader, an operations person, a business development person and a software engineer. They explained how the firm is organised and asked about it, plus a simple coding question (not given).
H18: Clock angles, then process checks
Report date: May 2017 · Location: United States · Result: Not stated
Excel quiz, 20 to 30 minutes. Recruiter phone call: the angle between the clock hands at several times. VBA-only take-home. Final: two pairs of interviewers described internal processes and asked how to improve or check them (Post-Trade Settlement Pipeline is the closest practice).
H19: Card puzzles and a case question
Report date: May 2016 · Location: United States · Result: Not stated
Resume screen, Excel take-home, a technical phone call with brainteasers such as card problems, and an onsite (no detail). Also a quantitative case-analysis question, round not given.
Keep practicing
- From these reports: Day of the Week Years Later (H03–H05), Heads in Fair Coin Flips (H03, H04), Digit Product Numbers (H04), Count the 2s (H08), Currency Haircut (H10), Biggest Move and Rising Streak (H16), Clock Hands (H18), Post-Trade Settlement (H16), Order Messages (H01), What value would you bring? (H10). Closest practice: Order Book Data Validation (H01), Next Distinct-Digit Date (H03), Post-Trade Settlement (H13, H18).
- Jane Street banks (sign-in needed): coding, Excel and data, behavioral, system design, low-level design.
- Jane Street interview page and the Experience feed.
In this series: Part 1 · Part 2 · Part 3 · Part 4 · Part 5 · Part 6 · Part 7 · Part 8 · Part 9 · Part 10
Sources: Anywhere useful interview info can be found.
Comments
0No comments yet — be the first to share what you know.